Thursday, April 3, 2025

Carolinas Credit Union League: H187 - About Those "Bullish" Financial Deserts......

         and Peoples, Planters, First Charter, Sou. Nat'l and...

😎 The Carolinas Credit Union League CEO Dan Schline "is pitching the legislation as a way to restore financial services to economically distressed communities vacated by traditional banks." [link - BNC]. 

The CCUL is making its' "bullish" pitch for credit union open membership to our legislators based on the abandonment of "economically distressed communities vacated by traditional banks."  The faux measure of abandonment used by CCUL is the number of bank branches closed over the last couple of decades in Tier 1 counties. 

😎 For the record, there is a far more legitimate and honest reason that many bank branches have been closed. Take a look at the list above. Most North Carolina communities used to have a "bank on every corner"! As the above mergers proceeded, especially after the banking debacle following 2010, many banks found that they owned branches "side-by-side" and consolidated locations. No North Carolina counties were "vacated" - that's just a "bullish" idea!

😎 Being honest, wouldn't it be better to count the number of branches which still exist in Tier 1 counties, rather than create a fiction of facts around those that were consolidated a decade ago? 

Here's the list of over 400+ bank branches operating today in those Tier 1 "financial deserts"[source - FDIC]:

1) ALEXANDER - 4 banks, 6 branches, $369 mil. deposits;  2) ANSON - 2 banks, 2 branches, $213 mil. deposits; 3) BEAUFORT  6 banks, 10 branches, $795 mil. deposits;  4) BERTIE - 1 bank, 1 branch, $126 mil. deposits; 5) BLADEN - 5 banks, 7 branches, $380 mil. deposits; 6) CALDWELL7 banks, 13 branches, $949 mil. deposits; 7) CASWELL - 2 banks, 2 branches, $79 mil. deposits; 8) CLEVELAND - 9 banks, 17 branches, $1,417 mil. deposits;  9) COLUMBUS - 6 banks, 10 branches, $1,391 mil. deposits; 10) CUMBERLAND - 15 banks, 51 branches, $4,855 mil. deposits; 11) EDGECOMBE  - 6 banks, 7 branches, $340 mil. deposits;  12) GRAHAM - 2 banks, 2 branches $171 mil. deposits;  13) GREENE  - 1 bank, 1 branch,  $127 mil. deposits; 14) HALIFAX 8 banks, 12 branches, $806 mil. deposits; 15) HERTFORD - 2 banks, 4 branches, $672 mil. deposits: 16) HOKE - 4 banks, 4 branches, $177 mil. deposits; 17) HYDE - 1 bank, 2 branches, $95 mil. deposits; 18) LENOIR - 7 banks, 7 branches, $997 mil. deposits;  19) MARTIN - 7 banks, 7 branches, $ 398 mil. deposits; 20) MCDOWELL - 3 banks, 3 branches, $354 mil. deposits;  21) MITCHELL - 1 bank, 2 branches, $293 mil. deposits; 22) MONTGOMERY - 3 banks, 7 branches, $379 mil. deposits; 23) NASH - 10 banks, 24 branches, $3,699 mil. deposits; 24) NORTHAMPTON - 1 bank, 1 branch, $70  mil. deposits;  25) PITT13 banks, 32 branches, $3,367 mil. deposits;  26) RANDOLPH11 banks, 23 branches, $2,027 mil. deposits;  27) RICHMOND - 5 banks, 6 branches, $490 mil. deposits; 28) ROBESON - 7 banks, 24 branches, $1,363  mil. deposits; 29) ROCKINGHAM - 9 banks, 19 branches, $1,321 mil. deposits; 30) RUTHERFORD - 9 banks, 11 branches, $833  mil. deposits; 31) SAMPSON - 5 banks, 10 branches, $668  mil. deposits; 32) SCOTLAND - 6 banks, 6 branches, $425 mil. deposits; 33) SURRY - 10 banks, 20 branches, $1,456 mil. deposits;  34) TYRRELL - 3 banks, 5 branches, $95 mil. deposits; 35) VANCE - 7 banks, 7 branches, $483 mil. deposits; 36) WARREN - 2 banks, 3 branches, $121 mil. deposits; 37) WASHINGTON - 1 bank, 1 branch, $69 mil. deposits; 38) WAYNE - 10 banks, 22 branches, $2,194  mil. deposits; 39) WILKES - 9 banks, 11 branches, $868 mil. deposits;  40) WILSON - 9 banks, 14 branches, $1,914 mil. deposits.    

😎 Not only are the 40 Tier 1 counties already broadly served, most by multiple N.C. banks, but 35 of the 40 Tier 1 counties are served by the most highly rated banks in the U.S. [link].

"Financial deserts"? ... definitely "bullish"!

 

                 

 

 

 


Wednesday, April 2, 2025

Carolinas Credit Union League Implies H187 Would Permit Service To "Widows And Orphans Trapped In N.C. Financial Deserts"...

    ... "bullish", to say the least!

 
😎 The Carolinas Credit Union League's CEO Dan Schline "is pitching the legislation [H187] as a way to restore financial services to economically distressed communities vacated by traditional banks." [link - BNC]

😎 Mr. Schline neglects to mention a few other "minor changes" which H187 would permit:

 Such as: "Amends GS 54-109.31: "... removes reference to “society association, copartnership or corporation having membership” and replaces it with “business or other entity having membership” so it is clear that any entity may be a member of a credit union."

😎 Translation: Any commercial, business, or corporation in the United States may join SECU, if H187 becomes law in North Carolina.

✅ Check it out for yourself at the summary of H187 prepared by the North Caolina School of Government. [here] Who should you believe? 

Don't know about you but that sounds like a commercial bank, not like a local, member-owned and focused credit union.

😎 Why is Dan Schline so reluctant to tell our Legislature the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? 

  What's your guess?