Sunday, April 6, 2025

H.187: Open Membership -The Elephant In The Room ...

https://www.leirpoll.com/images/misdirection.gif

Had mentioned in a prior post [link] that CEO Dan Schline, of the Carolinas' Credit Union League (CCUL), was running a "widows and orphans" hustle within H.187 "Credit Union Update".  Some folks asked what's that?

😎 A "widows and orphans clause" is used in politics to distract attention from the unsavory parts of proposed legislation one is pushing.  In addition to phrases which purport to protect widows and orphans; you often also pack in clauses which support veterans and the flag, praise Motherhood and apple pie, salute God and Country, and promise to "level the playing field". If you're in North Carolina, you always try to throw in support of NASCAR and BBQ for good measure!

The idea is to try and "set up" your opponents as heartless, greedy, selfish folks. The type of people, who not only won't support your "fair and reasonable" bill; but, also the type of opponents who would put widows and orphans out on the street, " diss" God and Country, hate your Mother and apple pie, eat quiche and don't know who drove the "#3" car. Got it?

😎 Last year with the failed H.410 "CU Updates" bill, CCUL's widows and orphans hustle read as follows:

Proposed language from failed H.410: "... any credit union organized under Articles 14A to 14L of this Chapter may also permit membership of the following located in this State: (1) Individuals and families that earn income at or below the federal poverty threshold. (2) Women-owned or minority-owned businesses. (3) Under-served areas, as defined by the Federal Credit Union Act."

There you go! with Dan Schline and the CCUL hoping to imply that opponents of H. 410 are against 1) poor folks, 2) women, 3) minorities, and of course  4) folks living in "under-served areas" - those famous "financial deserts" - which upon closer inspection are mainly national and state parks, bogs, swamps. and wildlife refuges.

Proposed language in the "new" H.187 CU Update bill - that "widows and orphans" gambit - has changed to: "To facilitate the provision of financial services to under-served populations and communities, a credit union organized under Articles 14A to 14L of this Chapter may also permit membership of the following located in this State:
(1) Individuals and families that earn income at or below the federal poverty threshold.
(2) Persons residing in census tracts in North Carolina where the center of population, as defined by the United States Census Bureau, is more than 8 miles from a bank branch, as defined in G.S. 53C-1-4."

         .... so once again while our State Legislators are misled with another "widow and orphans" hustle ...

       https://associatesmind.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/misdirection.png 

😎 Mr. Schline within the H.187 bill is still trying to pick North Carolina's pockets with language which also: 

  1. Removes all limitations on individual membership in North Carolina credit unions, 
  2. Adds unlimited membership and commercial lending for state, regional and national corporations.
  3. Authorizes higher risk investment of member funds outside of North Carolina.
  4. Encourages the export of jobs and capital outside of North Carolina. 
  5. Further dismantles member-owner rights and controls over N.C. credit unions.

.... while laughing at us and the State Legislature... all the way to the "new/new" bank!

Saturday, April 5, 2025

Carolinas Credit Union League H187: Trying To Legalize A "Work Around"?

 

            Houston we have a problem.

If you've been reading along about the "widows and orphans, Tier 1 counties" discussion in H187 [link], you might wonder what all the fuss is about [link]? Let those poor folks join for heavens sake!

Unfortunately the H187 "Credit Union Update" bill before the N.C. Legislature has little to do with all that [link]. H187 is about changing North Carolina law to permit open, anyone-can-join membership and commercial banking and investment authority to North Carolina credit unions [link]. Those changes do not conform with the original purpose nor principles of a credit union, nor do they conform with existing North Carolina law. 

Following the laws of our State is not "optional" last time I checked. But having failed for years to get its way on open membership in the North Carolina Legislature, the Carolinas Credit Union League (CCUL) decided to make up its own rules on open membership.  CCUL has a wonderful charitable arm - The Carolinas Credit Union Foundation - which helps many worthwhile causes. The CCUL has added "another benefit" for contributing to the Foundation - open credit union membership in North Carolina!

Here take a look at an actual example of open membership - courtesy of CCUL - from a credit union website:

✅ "Carolinas Credit Union Foundation: "You can become a member of ("XXXX") Credit Union and support an excellent cause!"

😎  "("XXXX") Credit Union is proud to partner with the Carolinas Credit Union Foundation. If we cannot qualify you in any other capacity, we will donate $15 to the Carolinas Credit Union Foundation in your name!"

😎 "How does the ("XXXX") CU & Carolinas Credit Union Foundation partnership work?"

"If you do not qualify for membership or as a family member, you can still open an account with us by becoming a Friend of the Foundation."

  • When you open your account, let us know you are interested in joining as a Friend of the Foundation.
  • We donate $15 to the Foundation at account opening for you to become a Friend of the Foundation.
  • We will report your membership to the Foundation and you are in!
  • Once you’re a ("XXXX") CU member, your immediate family becomes eligible for membership also.
😎 "Do I need to renew my Foundation membership to keep my ("XXXX") FCU account open?"

"No.  After your year of membership in the Foundation has expired, it is not necessary. Once a member of ("XXXX") CU, you're always a member!"

 

  So, no this not about "widows and orphans"... it's about ethics and integrity.