✅ Faye Nabhani, soon to be former CEO of SAFE Credit Union one way or the other, authored the letter to SAFE members strongly supporting the merger and asking member support. (See the full text of her letter: [here!])
✔ As the disclosures in her letter reveal in #'s 2, 3, 4 below, Ms. Nabhani will benefit by at least $4,358,000 from the merger. Lots of folks will probably "get exercised" about a $4.3 million payout by their folksy, community-minded, non-profit, cooperative.
Maybe they should or, of course, it could also just be envy and jealousy - y'know that human nature thing!
- "Ms. Nabhani’s SERP and change-in-control agreement were established prior to, and independent of, the proposed merger. Because BECU does not offer an equivalent program, Ms. Nabhani’s existing agreements will be terminated, and its value will be paid out as a retention agreement tied to continued employment through the post-merger transition period."
- "For the SERP portion of the agreement, Ms. Nabhani will be eligible for three separate post-close payments up to $1,075,000 each (totaling up to $3,225,000)."
- "For the Retention portion of the agreement, Ms. Nabhani will be eligible for three separate post-close payments up to$361,000 each (totaling up to $1,083,000)."
- "A one-time $50,000 bonus, as described above."
- "Separately, upon closing of the proposed merger, Ms. Nabhani has agreed closer to be employed by the Continuing Credit Union in the position of Market President for the Greater Sacramento Region. Upon employment by BECU after closing, Ms. Nabhani’s total future annual compensation, including base salary, incentive opportunities, and employer retirement contributions, is expected to decrease by approximately $504,710."
✔ But while you recover from that fit of jealousy and envy, please consider two other points.
- First, regardless of what the Board and Ms. Nabhani claim about everything remaining the same ("We can build on all that SAFE has stood for over the past 85 years."); there will be a change-in-control at SAFE [see #1] - no if's, and's, or but's. SAFE will no longer belong to the Sacramento community - period!
- Second, in reading #5, you might get the impression that Ms. Nabhani is making a huge sacrifice in this merger with her compensation decreasing by @ $504,710! Trick question: "What is her new, "low" compensation?" (According to IRS filings @$750,000 annually!)
😎 So. if Ms. Nabhani stays 1 year, she will take home over $5+million, 3 years over $6.5+ million, 5 years over $8+ million.... "As a member-owned credit union, everything we do is guided by one simple commitment: doing what is best for you.
😎 Two SAFE Board members are accepting seats on the BECU board and will be each paid $125,000 per year.
"People Helping People"... some perhaps more than others?
'We Do the Wrong Thing the Right Way'.....
ReplyDeletenew slogan for them ...
Below are rankings from the Top 10 largest CUs - with SAFE added into the list; showing CEO approval rating from high to low, plus overall CU rating, and Would recommend %
ReplyDeleteTop 10 CUs CU CEO Approval CU rating Recmnd
SchoolsFirst FCU 86% 3.6 67%
Mountain America CU 86% 3.8 78%
America First CU 83% 3.6 60%
Suncoast CU 82% 3.9 72%
First Tech FCU 77% 3.4 53%
Navy Federal CU 63% 3.6 63%
PenFed 58% 3.3 58%
SAFE CU 56% 3.7 69%
NCSECU 49% 3.6 60%
Golden 1 CU 49% 3.0 43%
BECU 47% 3.0 41%
What are these rankings of?
DeleteCategories are : Top 10 largest CUs +SAFE ; overall CU CEO approval rating %; overall rating of the CU on a 5 point scale; and whether folks (%) would recommend the CU to friends.
DeleteThis looks like rankings from employee/member online review groups like Glassdoor/Indeed. Hard to determine reliability.
Thanks. So basically 69% of SAFE employees, many of whom will lose their jobs after systems covert, recommend SAFE to others, while the SAFE CEO is representing that there will be more employee opportunities within a strongly aligned culture and a bright future by merging with a credit union where only 41% of its employees would recommend working there to someone else?
DeleteAnd then sells to members and employees the strong culture alignment while being absorbed a by a credit union where less than half its employees approve of the CEO and has an approval rating that is dead last among peer credit unions?
be wary of the dangers of deceptions of the world ... the enemy is the father of lies ... those who follow him will lie to you also...
ReplyDeleteThe SAFE Board evidently knows SAFE members won't approve the merger so they've decided to "sidestep" the vote and "appeal" over the members' heads for approval to the state regulator.
ReplyDeleteHere take a look:
https://thecudaily.com/even-as-it-plans-to-appeal-to-state-regulator-if-vote-doesnt-go-its-way-safe-cu-opens-voting-on-merger-of-becu/